Clément CHENEVIER, Corentin ARNOULT & François ROULLAUD write...
This monument
is situated on Marinette Menut square in Riom. It is a very austere rectangular
stone with no colour.
Five naked
people are shown. Their eyes are closed and they look very sad. They appear to be prisoners who have suffered some form of violence. There are three adults, a boy,
hands tied, and a baby, asleep in the arms of one of the adults (it’s
difficult to see if it’s a man or a woman). One of the men is on his knees, looking upwards,
perhaps at his jailer. The cringing older man seems to be hurt.
Around the monument,
a metal fence, 50 centimetres high, looks like barbed wires.
Below, there
is a plaque to commemorate the bravery of all the resistance martyrs, asking
us not to forget the horrors perpetrated during the Nazi occupation of France: “Aux
martyres de la Résistance, pour perpétuer le souvenir des atrocités commises.”
There is a stone
plaque on which is written: “Ici, terre des camps de la mort et cendres des
martyres”, meaning: “Soil from the death camps and ash of the martyrs.”
There is a second stone plaque on which is written: “Les
déportés, internés, résistants patriotes, survivants des camps et prisons, de
la barbarie et du fascisme. N'oubliez pas notre serment et notre combat pour la
liberté et la paix dans notre monde. Soyez maintenant les défenseurs de notre
idéal. Plus jamais ça. En l'an 2001”, which means: “The
deported, interned, patriotic resistance fighters, survivors of the camps and
prisons, of barbarism and fascism. Do not forget our oath and our fight for
freedom and peace in the world. Be now the upholders of our ideal. Never again.
The year 2001.” The fact that the plaque was put on the monument in 2001 shows
that the atrocities of the German Occupation were so terrible that they are felt
even in the 21st century.
On the other end
of the street, there is another plaque, just on the right of the “Pharmacy des
Puys”, which is the old pharmacy of the husband of Marinette Menut: “Marinette Menut, lieutenant pharmacien blessée au combat de
Saint Just (Cantal) le 22 juin 1944, torturée et fusillée par la gestapo
française et allemande sans avoir parlé à Clermont Ferrand le 19 juillet 1944 à
l’âge de 30 ans.”
All these
inscriptions commemorate the Résistance; the fighters wanted us to remember
their struggle for the freedom of our Nation and for it to serve as an example.
The monument is regularly decorated and inhabitants of Riom stand and
meditate in front of it in accordance with the Résistance fighters’ wish.
The sculptor, Raoul Mabru (born 1882-1957) made eighteen other such commemorative monuments. He was from the Auvergne and specialized in commemorative monuments for WW1 and WW2. Some of his monuments are quite famous, notably the monument for the victims of the Gestapo in Royat. He did not just make patriotic sculptures.
Marinette
Menut, née Anne-Mary Lafaye, was born in Laprugne on 16th May 1914.
After having studied medicine, she married a young chemist, Max Menut, who was mobilized
in 1939, made a prisoner but who escaped. They created a chemist shop in Riom
called “La Pharmacie Nouvelle.”
Interviews of local people on what they think of the monument in Marinette Menue Square:
Young man, walking past: “I have of course noticed this
statue before, though, honestly, I’ve never really paid much attention to it. I
do not like it particularly… The contrast between the black and white stones is
ok. I respect what it stands for, this monument. I’m proud that our town has
put up a memorial to such heroic Résistance fighters! I think the fact that it
has been put up near a school is a great idea, it will remind the pupils about
the war. It’s a shame though that it is in a carpark! It’s not very convenient to
get to it, and it’s obviously impossible to meditate in silence in front of it!”
Fabienne, a middle-aged woman who goes frequently
past the monument: “It’s
really badly placed! They should put it somewhere where it can be seen
properly. I mean, the triumphal arch is in a big square of Riom, everybody sees
it, so why can’t we put this monument somewhere like that? This sculpture is
beautiful because of the precision of the sculpture, it shows really well the emotions
of the people. I prefer this sort of memorial to those patriotic statues
because it denounces more the horror of the fighting. This statue shows the
suffering of the Resistance fighters, it has more meaning, a stronger message.
It reminds me of the memorial in Gentioux (in Creuse), do you know it? There’s
a phrase on it: “Maudite soit la guerre!” (“War be damned!”) with the statue of
a child. I prefer a message which condemns the suffering rather than one glorifying
war, because, today, this monument is for all the victims of war in the world.”
A dialogue with God...
God: What’s the matter with these humans; they are always fighting each other! Having to send my angels to Earth every time these limited little creatures start quarrelling is becoming tedious!
A dialogue with God...
God: What’s the matter with these humans; they are always fighting each other! Having to send my angels to Earth every time these limited little creatures start quarrelling is becoming tedious!
Kneeling man: God, please
don’t blame us! Look at me and my friends, we are French, good French patriots!
We are fighting for the freedom of France, the beautiful country you have
always treasured! Please help us, we need your help to get rid of the evil Nazis!
Standing man: Stop imploring
God! If He existed, He would have prevented this war. He would punish all those
who kill their fellow men… No, we are all alone. This world is bad, and we alone
are to blame…
Kneeling man: Well,
we’ve got nothing to lose. If He does exist, then maybe He will help us?
Standing man: Don’t
be ridiculous, no one can help us. We can only help ourselves! Don’t be such a
coward, get up and fight!
Kneeling man: Dear
God, I’m sorry about my friend, he doesn’t believe in You.
God: I’m listening. You
were telling me about the horrors and atrocities of the creatures you described
as bloodthirsty monsters?
Kneeling man: Yes,
the Gestapo are the Devil’s henchmen!
God: Hmm… Maybe the Germans
aren’t as good as I thought they were. I’ll think about how
to punish them.
Kneeling man: Thank
You, oh God! You are a generous God.
God: You’re welcome,
My son.



































